In desperate need of a milk saver? You have a choice to make between two popular brands: Haakaa vs Milkies. Which one should you go for? If I have to rate the products based on cost, effectiveness, and function then I’m putting my money on the Haakaa milk saver. Read on to find out more.
Breast milk is undoubtedly a precious commodity. Even the smallest amount is packed with nutrients that your growing baby needs. That’s reason enough for not wanting even a single drop to go to waste. Pick a milk saver and you never have to worry about that again.
My Top Picks
- Best Overall – Haakaa Manual Breast Pump Milk Saver
- Best for Discretion – Milkies Milk-Saver
Haakaa vs Milkies – What You Need to Know
I can promise you that both Haakaa and Milkies are no stranger to the baby market. They indeed know a thing or two about designing baby products that offer practical solutions to nursing moms. This can unfortunately make it difficult for you to make a decision between the two. But that’s what this section is for; to give you all the information you need in order to make the right decision. I’ll cover aspects such as the brands in question including similarities and differences. By the time you’re done reading, you’ll know exactly which brand to pick.
A Bit About the Brands
The brand Haakaa is synonymous with natural and eco-friendly products. Ever since its inception, this New Zealand family-owned company has been delivering safe and non-toxic products. Their product offering ranges from breast pumps to skincare products for both moms and babies. The company also sells teething products, feeding spoons, and bowls. Milkies was started in 2013 with the sole purpose of providing safe and high-quality products for nursing moms. Breast pumps and milk storage products are part of the brand’s product offering. They even go as far as formulating supplements for lactating mothers and creams for cracked nipples caused by breastfeeding. Think of both companies as your one-stop shop for both nursing moms and babies.
What the Two Milk Savers Have in Common
I’ll start off by citing the similarities found in these two products:
- They are both designed to save each and every drop of breast milk ensuring that none goes to waste.
- Both are made of BPA and phthalate-free materials to take care of your little one’s safety concerns.
- They are designed for a secure and comfortable fit.
- Both help relieve pressure from engorged breasts.
- Both units don’t have any cords and neither do they require assembly.
- They are both easy to clean.
What Sets the Two Apart?
While they serve more or less the same purpose and have a few similarities, they also have some differences as I’ll list below:
- Capacity: The Milkies milk saver can hold a maximum of 2oz of liquid at any given time. The Haakaa milk saver can hold slightly more liquid — a total of 3oz.
- Function: The Milkies milk saver doubles as a nipple shield which allowing a cracked nipple time to heal. Unfortunately, the Haakaa milk saver doesn’t offer this function. What it does offer is a powerful natural suction which makes the product also serve as a manual breast pump. There’s no pumping involved with the Milkies milk saver.
- Cleaning: Though they are both easy to clean, the Milkies product is safe for both dishwashing and hand-washing. However, the manufacturer strictly prohibits steaming this milk saver. On the other hand, you can boil the Haakaa milk saver or place it in a steamer for at least two to three minutes.
- Extras: The Milkies milk saver comes with a convenient stand where you can place the container when it’s full. Unfortunately, the Haakaa milk saver doesn’t come with this feature.
How to Make the Right Choice
To make the right pick it’s important to consider the following factors:
- Maintenance because you want to pick a unit that allows for easy cleanup.
- Materials used in the construction of the product. Is it made of baby-safe products? Is it durable?
- Comfort concerns because you want a unit that attaches comfortably on the breast.
- User-friendly design free from unnecessary cords for easy handling and traveling with.
- Leak effective design to minimize spillage.
- Weight since it’s advisable to pick a portable unit that allows for easy handling.
Best Overall – Haakaa Manual Breast Pump Milk Saver
Pick this brand if you want a milk saver that also serves as a breast pump. It’s extremely lightweight and portable allowing for easy handling. You’ll appreciate the leak-proof cap design that minimizes accidental spills or leaks.
Who It’s For
This product is ideal for traveling with.
Why You Should Consider It
This Haakaa milk saver is made of high-grade silicone which takes care of your durability concerns. It’s also free from harmful chemicals, features a sleek design, and is easy to clean. Plus it’s also considerably discreet and allows your partner to express milk almost anywhere. And there are some great ways to store your Haakaa between uses.
Product Information
- Dimensions: 3.31 X 3.31 X 5,75”
- Weight: 4.6oz
- Materials: BPA, PVC, Phthalate-free
Pros
- Quality construction
- Holds a sizeable amount of milk
- Powerful natural suction
Cons
- Presents a learning curve initially
- May cause oversupply
- Some women might find the powerful suction uncomfortable
Best Discreet Design – Milkies Milk-Saver
Pick this product if you don’t want your partner to have to deal with uncomfortable nursing pads or milk-stained shirts. This milk saver is not only discreet but comfortable to wear all day making it ideal for the working mother.
Who It’s For
This product is perfect for the working mother given the discreet design.
Why You Should Consider It
I like how this milk saver also acts as a nipple shield. The fact that it’s made free of harmful chemical materials that might harm your baby is also a plus. And the baby stand is a thoughtful feature.
Product Information
- Dimensions: 9.49 x 6.1 x 2.8”
- Weight: 10.2oz
- Materials: BPA, Phthalate-free
Pros
- Comfortable
- Discreet
- Contains leaks effectively
Cons
- Expensive
- Only holds 2oz of milk
- Some people might find the stand too bulky (and unnecessary)
FAQ
Are milk savers necessary?
If you don’t want any precious baby milk going to waste or your partner going through countless nursing pads in a day, then you’re better off buying milk savers.
Do breasts need time to refill?
Not really, at any given time, nursing breasts are never entirely empty. However, with fewer periods of nursing or pumping, less milk is produced. Continuous nursing is required for a constant flow of milk.
Conclusion
It’s clear: aside from milk storage containers and conventional breast pumps such as Haakaa, Bumblebee or Naturebond, nursing moms should definitely add milk savers to that list.
Of the two brands discussed here, I advise you to pick the Haakaa milk saver. It’s cheaper than the Milkies product. But even with the lower price tag it also serves as a breast pump plus it holds more milk. To top it off, it’s lightweight, portable, and durable. Sure, it presents a bit of a learning curve initially but in no time, the pumping process will be pretty easy and straightforward.
Last update on 2024-04-19 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API
