Play-Doh vs Plasticine – What’s the difference?

Playdoh Toys

Most parents may find it messy, but Play-Doh and Plasticine are among the favorite things for kids to play with. It’s fun and it also awakens the kid’s art and creativity skills. However, selecting the best product can be challenging. We these two brands to help you choose the one that fits your kid’s demands.

Main Features – Similarities and Differences

After using both products for a while, and researching them, I found a few differences and similarities between the two. Take a look at these below.


Both Play-Doh and Plasticine are made from safe materials, making them harmless to kids. Both products are non-toxic, odorless, smooth, and soft for little fingers. Here is a video of why Play-Doh is great for kids.


Both products are reusable, hence durable, allowing them to be used over and over again for years. There are several ways to revive dry Play-Doh and Plasticine so research on that in case yours gets dry with time. However, even with frequent use, you will get the best out of these. I’ve had mine for a while now and they are still all good.


Although both products are made from different compounds, their use for children’s games is the same. Kids use them to mold and make toys, numbers, and whatever else they can come up with using their imagination. The possibilities are endless.


Both Play-Doh and Plasticine modeling compounds come in many colors allowing kids to create vibrant creative toys.


Both products are easy to clean; however, Plasticine is much easier to wash. Cleaning Play-Doh may take some time to remove the stains from the table surfaces and the surroundings after playing.


Play-Doh is water-based, while Plasticine is oil-based. As a result, the latter doesn’t dry and it holds its shape better. On the other hand, Play-Doh, if allowed to dry, can form permanent sculptures.

My Top Picks

Play-Doh My Little Pony Playset

My Little Pony Play-Doh playset lets your kids create their own magical world. With a rainbow of nine Play-Doh colors, you can create all kinds of my little pony friends, including earth ponies, unicorns, princess ponies, and more. You can use the four pony bases and molds to shape your ponies then give them beautiful rainbow manes and cutie marks.

Product info

  • Weight: 1 pound
  • Recommended age: 3 years and up
Play-Doh My Little Pony Make 'n Style Ponies (Amazon Exclusive)

Why you may love it

  • Very safe – the molds are made from non-toxic material hence very secure for kids to play with
  • Various colors – kids will love it and have lots of fun playing with this playset due to its different color combinations


  • Very soft and perfect for little fingers
  • Easy to clean when it dries up
  • Non-toxic
  • Can be reused
  • Does not stick to the hands
  • Durable
  • Lightweight


  • Can dry if left out too long
  • Creations can crack when dried
  • Germs can spread because it is reusable

Play-Doh Doctor Drill ‘n Fill Set

Ready to play the dentist? The Play-Doh Doctor Drill and fill playset for kids may be the perfect toy to get your little loved having fun. The set comes with a mouth, play-Doh, tweezers, a mirror, toothbrush, tooth mold, and a drill. The kid can create teeth, place them inside the play-Doh mouth, and perform all the duties of a dentist. This set can be used to teach your kids how to keep their teeth clean at the same time having fun.

Play-Doh Doctor Drill 'n Fill Set

Product info

  • Weight: 1.65 pound
  • Recommended age: 3 years and up

Why you may love it

  • Durable – it has good quality, and the kid can use it for many years to come
  • It encourages creative play – a child can take on the role of a dentist and pretend to be attending to a patient by filling cavities, making braces, and brushing teeth


  • Multi-color play dough
  • High quality
  • Made using safe material
  • Easy to use


  • Drill uses batteries
  • Noisy while spinning and drilling

Dough Tools – 5 Piece Assortment

Dough tools are great toys for kids to work and play with any dough. The set consists of a flower roller, round cutting roller, zig-zag cutting roller, craft tool and plastic blade for cutting dough. The pizza-like cutter will provide your kid with endless fun while playing safely with these harmless tools.

Product info

  • Weight: 4.2 ounces
  • Recommended age: 3 years and up

Why you may love it

  • Easy to clean – the plastic dough tools are easy to clean
  • Safe – these cutting tools are reliable for kids to use without supervision as they are made of plastic


  • Durable
  • Bright colored suitable for kids
  • Nice sizes
  • Easy to use
  • Effective and safe


  • The rolling pin doesn’t move


Whichever you choose, you can never go wrong with either of them. Both are made from non-toxic material which is perhaps the most important quality of all. They are both affordable, easy to mold, and with the accessories, your little one will have a lot of fun and can exercise her creativity. My daughter does for sure.

Another popular product is made by Hasbro, their Crayola and therefore you might want to read my other article Crayola Dough vs Play-Doh comparison or Softee Dough vs Play-Doh comparison.

By the way, did you know you can bake Play-Doh? It’s a great way to create long-lasting memorabilia.

Last update on 2024-05-07 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *