Graco Sense2Soothe vs EveryWay Soother vs 4moms mamaRoo – which one should I pick?

Baby playing with soft toys

Comforting your child can become rather tedious, especially when they get fussy. However, with this review, you’ll get a comparison of the Graco Sense2Soothe vs EveryWay Soother vs 4moms Mamaroo. These are some of the leading swing options available to help you with keeping your child comfortable when you need a break. Therefore choosing one is not easy but no worries, I’m here to help you with your selection process.

If I were to pick a new one, I’d go for the Graco Sense2Soothe device.

What they are and why you should buy them

Being a new parent can be overwhelming at times, especially when you need to get things done, and your baby needs your attention. That’s part of the reason automatic swings have become such a huge hit with parents. The Graco Sense2Soothe, EveryWay Soother, and 4moms Mamaroo fall under the automatic swing category of baby soothers. They each have unique features that I’ll break down in this review.

Differences and similarities


How much you are willing to pay significantly impacts where you can place your focus. Out of these three options, the 4moms Mamaroo currently has the highest price tag. However, it isn’t the most expensive by that much most of the time (price can vary). If you need a more affordable solution, the Sense2Soothe baby swing would be your ideal option.


Anything that moves your baby around needs to have safety features to keep your kid secure. All three of these automated baby soothers come with secure straps to hold your baby in place. They’re adjustable, as their seats can accommodate babies of different weights. Ensure that you adjust them to the point that you feel your child is secure yet comfortable.


For these swings to prove their worth, your child needs to stay in them without fussing. As such, the baby seats need to provide an exceptional level of comfort for your young one. The Sense2Soothe, EveryWay Soother, and 4moms Mamaroo all have extra padding on their seats, which makes them comfortable even after extended periods within the swings.

The seats can also recline. The Mamaroo leads in this regard since it can completely recline. The rest maintain a slightly raised angle, even at their lowest levels.


You won’t sit in one position with your child the whole day. To enable you to move around with ease, both the Sense2Soothe and the EveryWay Soother come with detachable seats. Not only can these easily be carried around, but they also function as manual rocking seats. The Mamaroo, however, is a fixed unit that cannot be detached.

Type of motion

Do you need a swaying motion or swinging movement? Whatever the case, all three of these offer you varying levels of motion to keep your child calm. The EveryWay Soother tops the list because it can move around in 16 different ways, which adds variety to soothing your tot. This is the case as the seat can be adjusted, allowing for more motion. The Sense2Soothe comes next with eight relaxing movements for your child to enjoy. Last on the list in terms of movements is the Mamaroo, with its five different soothing movements, mimicking a parent’s rocking styles. Here’s a quick demo video of the winner out of the three regarding freedom of movement.

Intended purpose

Would you like something that lulls your baby to sleep or one that keeps them calm whenever you’re not holding them? These tend to be some of the questions you need to get answered before purchase. Actually all three swings can all keep your child relaxed, help them fall asleep, or calm them when they’re fussy.

Ease of cleaning

Babies often make a mess such as spilling milk everywhere. So whenever you need to clean your baby swing, how easy will it be? With Mamaroo, you have an easy-to-remove fabric that can be machine-washed. The two Graco options enable you to either remove the cloth or wipe it down to keep it clean.


Your baby will be resting in these soothers several times a day. Do they have well-built structures that can hold them up? That’s the beauty of it. By using steel and plastic, these baby swing frames are sturdy enough to hold 25-pound babies with ease.


After assembling your swing, does it stand up straight, or does it lean to one side? An uneven frame would indicate that you’ve constructed it in the wrong way. Follow the instructions to the letter so that you can notice early whether your purchase has a defect. A swing with a shaky or uneven base could put your child at risk of toppling over with the entire swing. The Sense2Soothe, EveryWay Soother, and Mamaroo all come with flat bottoms.

Plug-in or batteries

When it comes to kids’ accessories, finding an option you can plug in is always a plus. That’s because battery cells usually get used up quite fast with frequent usage. All three of these options come with a plug-in feature to enable the automated functionalities to work.

Entertainment features

Can your child stay occupied while being in these swings? The Mamaroo comes with four songs, a toy mobile, and an MP3 plugin to help you provide entertainment for your baby. The Sense2Soothe and EveryWay Soother also have entertainment options that include up to 15 sounds and melodies as well as hanging mobiles with soft toys.

Which One to Choose?

These three swings certainly do a lot. However, which one should you choose? Based on the criteria outlined above, I’m positive that you’ll be able to narrow down your search in a short time. Start by deciding what you need from a swing. Is it the price, the range of motion, the color options, or other criteria that determine what’s best for you? Set up a priority list of features based on level of importance. From there, you can check which one of the three options best suits your needs.

Graco Sense2Soothe Baby Swing with Cry Detection Technology

If you happen to have a newborn, then this is an option you should consider. It’s an electronically powered baby swing that comes with a detachable rocking chair. The swing has a built-in microphone that senses when your baby is uneasy and automatically starts to soothe them. It achieves this through its eight different soothing options, making it unnecessary for you to keep running to your child when they’re fussy. The rocker switches the intensity of the soothing automatically from the point when your baby becomes uneasy up until they calm down again. It also comes with three adjustable speed levels, up to 15 songs, and two vibration options. You also have the opportunity to save your preferred setting choices with the Sense2Soothe. The swing can accommodate babies between 5.5 – 25 pounds, while the rocker is suitable for babies between 5.5 – 18 pounds. It’s a great choice for parents with newborns. The swing operates when plugged in, and the seat can manually rock once you detach it.

Product information

  • Package Dimensions: 18.90 x 28.35 x 32.28 inches
  • Package weight: 21.94 pounds
  • Color: Sailor, Birdie


  • Easy to clean
  • Comes with a sturdy frame
  • Has cry detection technology
  • Automatically adjusts settings to soothe your baby
  • Can work as a swing
  • Has a portable rocker
  • Ideal for younger infants
  • Easy to adjust settings


  • Doesn’t automatically stop rocking once your baby falls asleep
View on Amazon

4moms MamaRoo 4 baby swing

This swing mimics a parent’s movements when trying to soothe their baby. The seat can move in a car-ride, wave, kangaroo, rock-a-by, or tree swing motion, depending on which one will calm down your child. Mesh fabric covers the seat, keeping your little one comfortable while they’re seated. You can even use the removable infant insert for newborns. To clean the seat’s fabric, simply remove and machine wash before returning it. When you’d like your child to stay alert, there is a toy mobile attached with three balls, a mirror, a crinkle ball, and a rattle. In case you’d like to change the settings from where you are, you can do so with your smartphone. The 4moms MamaRoo connects to your device via Bluetooth, enabling you to adjust different settings. However, you need to place it close to a socket so that you can plug it in.

Product information

  • Package dimensions: 25.5 x 19.5 x 33 inches
  • Package weight: 19 pounds
  • Color: Grey Classic, Multi Plush, Cool Mesh, Silver Plush, Black Classic


  • Comes with four in-built soothing sounds
  • Bluetooth connection enables you to change settings
  • Supports instructions from both Android and iOS devices
  • Easy to assemble
  • Seat can recline up to a completely flat position
  • Doesn’t need batteries to operate
  • Easy to clean
  • Has an mp3 plugin
  • Can support babies up to 25 pounds


  • Some consumers reported that bluetooth function sometimes doesn’t operate reliably
View on Amazon

Graco EveryWay Soother Baby Swing with Removable Rocker

With Graco’s swing, your baby gets more range of movement for soothing them. The swing comes with eight movement options. However, the seat is multidirectional. That allows for either back and forth, or side to side movement. This feature gives you a total of 16 relaxing motions for your child. Whenever you need to go to another room, you can remove the seat. It doubles as a portable rocker, so you can still keep your little one close. The seat position can be adjusted to ensure your baby’s comfort while awake or sleeping. You’ll also find a removable head supporter for your infant. The swing also comes with a toy mobile attached to keep your child occupied when you cannot play with them. To enable the use of the automated functions, you can plug the swing into an outlet to power it.

Graco EveryWay Soother Baby Swing with Removable Rocker, Tristan

Product information

  • Package dimensions: 25.5 x 28 x 35 inches
  • Package weight: 22.5 pounds
  • Color: Tristan, Josephine


  • Seat is multidirectional
  • Offers 16 relaxing movements to soothe your baby
  • Has six adjustable speed options
  • Baby seat can be removed and used as a rocker
  • Comes with cry detection technology
  • Baby seat can recline to three different levels
  • Comes with vibration settings
  • You get 15 melodies and sounds for your baby
  • Functions by being plugged in
  • No batteries required for automated functionalities


  • Its instruction manual is a bit hard to understand
View on Amazon


Hopefully my review of Graco Sense2Soothe vs EveryWay Soother vs Mamaroo with its breakdown of the features, and benefits will mean that you can make the right decision easier and faster.

These three options rank high because they have plenty of features to help out any new parent while they learn the ropes. Having one of these options in your home should help you manage things easier, at least with one less cry per day than before. At least that was my experience with the Graco EveryWay Soother. And once your child can sit on its own you might want to consider also baby jumpers, another category that could free up time for you and keep them busy.

Another product comparison you might want to look into is Graco Sense2Snooze vs SNOO since SNOO is also a very popular smart device.

Last update on 2024-05-16 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *