MamaRoo vs RockaRoo vs Graco Simple Sway Review

Baby chair

Has your baby ever cried out loud and you wanted to pull out your hair? Sometimes, all you want is a break, and that’s where baby swings come into play.

Swings soothe your child, so you can catch a break and remain sane. In this 4moms mamaRoo vs rockaRoo vs Graco Simple Sway review I show you the pros and cons of each product and other information so you can decide which is best for you and your little one.

My Top Picks

What baby swings are and why you should consider them

Younger babies like being held and rocked for the better part of the day, but the truth is, you also need a break, so you have enough energy to care for them properly. Without such breaks, you risk being a zombie by the evening, especially if other duties need to get sorted around the house. With a baby swing, you can keep your child entertained and soothed without always holding them. There are even lightweight options that you can move around the house easily.

Main features – similarities and differences

Ease of assembly

After purchasing your baby swing, you’ll need to assemble it. The 4moms mamaRoo and rockaRoo options are quite easy to assemble. With the Graco Simple Sway, you’ll need to set aside more time for putting it together. Some parents say the assembly instructions aren’t easy to follow.

Motion options

The motions of a baby swing are vital because, without the right movement, the swing won’t do its job correctly, and you won’t get the help you need. What you choose will highly depend on what your little munchkin wants. If they need different movements, select the mamaRoo because it has up to 25 different motions. The other two options only move in fixed directions. You’ll get a side to side sway with the Graco Simple Sway, while the rockaRoo moves forwards and back. This video shows how to use the 4moms mamaRoo swing.


The essence of a swing is to move the baby around. It’s essential to have safety features that ensure that your child won’t fall off. The mamaRoo, rockaRoo, and Graco Simple Sway all come with safety harnesses to secure your child’s position on the seat. You’ll get a 5-point harness with the Graco option, while the 4moms models come with a 3-point waist harness.


Even when you need help, you don’t want to hurt your bank account while doing it. For those on a budget, the Graco Simple Sway is an excellent option. The mamaRoo costs the most while the rockaRoo is somewhere in the middle. Whichever option you choose, you will get enough features to help soothe your little one when you need it the most.


Not all baby swings are suitable for all ages. Different manufacturers have different limits to ensure your child’s comfort. It’s also a way for them to guarantee the safety of the device which you’re purchasing. When shopping, look at the age limit and also check the maximum and minimum height and weight restrictions since not all babies grow at the same rate. All three options are suitable for newborns. However, the maximum weight capacity for the 4moms versions is 25 pounds, while the Graco Simple Sway can hold up to a maximum of 30 pounds.

Other features

Different baby swing models come with additional perks that make them better suited to your child’s needs. These could include features such as mechanical mobiles, vibration settings, in-built sounds, among others. All three of these options come with in-built sounds. Graco Simple Sway comes with a vibration setting. Both of the 4moms options come with mp3 capabilities. However, you can control the mamaRoo’s settings through Bluetooth. This setting allows you to monitor and change settings from a distance.

Which one to choose?

A baby swing is one of those items that only your baby can decide whether they like it or not. That aside, you can still make your purchase based on things like your budget and the safety features available. In case the price isn’t an issue for you, be sure to check all the swing’s highlights to ensure you buy something fitting. For instance, if you’d like something with a side to side motion, the Graco Simple Sway costs less than the rockaRoo but sways from left to right. To be on the safe side, however, it’s best to pick the best overall option, the 4moms mamaRoo, because it offers more than the other options.

Best Overall – 4moms mamaRoo 4 Baby Swing

Product information

  • Assembled dimensions: 33×19.5×25.5 inches
  • Weight: 19 pounds
  • Color: Dark Grey, Silver Plush, Black Classic, Multi Plush, Grey Classic

Why you should consider it

The 4moms mamaRoo 4 Baby Swing has its reputation around giving a lot of comfort for your baby. It comes with five diverse motions to try to mimic a parent’s up and down movements, and side to side comforting motions. These are the car ride, tree swing, wave, kangaroo, and rock a bye motions. It has different speed levels, and you get up to 25 movement variations to help soothe your little one. Apart from that, this option also comes with sounds. These come in handy in case you need to distract your child when they start getting fussy for no reason, which usually happens quite a bit with younger infants (or at least with mine). The seat can be reclined or placed upright when it’s time for your young one to get active. Depending on your preference for your child, you can choose to go with plush seat fabrics, which are softer, woven polyester seat fabrics, or the cool mesh fabric, which enhances air circulation.

Who it’s best suited for

  • Newborns as well as children under 25 pounds.


  • Offers motions similar to those of a comforting parent
  • You can connect an mp3 device for more entertainment options
  • Pairs with Android and iOS devices to adjust settings through Bluetooth
  • Seat fabrics are machine washable
  • Has a crinkle, mirror, and rattle toy balls


  • Bit pricey
View on Amazon

Best compact design – 4moms rockaRoo

Product information

  • Assembled dimensions: 29.6×16.5×27.5 inches
  • Weight: 11.5 pounds
  • Color: Grey Classic, Dark Grey

Why you should consider it

In case you’re short on space, then the 4moms rockaRoo’s compact design will suit your home better. Its frame also places it much closer to the ground. The low profile makes it easier for you to monitor your baby from a nearby seat. You have five speed choices to help you modify the motion to your child’s liking. To entertain your child, you can upload their preferred music and soothing sounds to an mp3 and connect it to the rockaRoo. Your little one will also have some removable toy balls to keep them occupied. In case of any messes, you can remove the seat fabrics easily and clean them. They’re also machine washable. To enable the gliding motion, you need to plug the adapter into a wall outlet. There’s a 3-point harness to keep your baby secure while they’re in the 4moms rockaRoo. You have the option to use inserts for younger children to increase their comfort. However, these need to be purchased separately.

Who it’s best suited for

  • For newborn babies to children who weigh a maximum of 25 pounds.


  • Easy to assemble
  • Doesn’t use batteries
  • Spare parts are available for purchase
  • A compact build
  • You can choose the seat fabrics
  • Comes with in-built music options


  • It only moves in a back and forth motion
View on Amazon

Best budget – Graco Simple Sway Baby Swing

Graco Simple Sway Swing

Product information

  • Assembled dimensions: 30x31x38 inches
  • Weight: 17.2 pounds
  • Color: Sketch Safari, Abbington, Teddy, Stratus

Why you should consider it

The Graco Simple Sway Baby Swing has a compact design that comes with a hanging toy mobile as well as in-built songs for entertainment. You can either choose to plug it to activate the electronically powered functions or use batteries. That makes it possible for you to move to different rooms with the swing, as necessary. You can also use it outdoors by switching to batteries. The swing sways from side to side, with a gentle vibration added to enhance the soothing experience. You can adjust the speed of the swaying whenever the need arises to keep your baby happy. That’s the case whether they’re having fun, or they’re ready to wind down. The vibration setting can be adjusted through its two levels to give your baby the right amount of soothing. The seat is deep with plush cushioning for maximum comfort. For smaller babies, you can use the included infant insert to offer them additional support. You also have a 5-point harness to keep your little one secure as they swing.

Who it’s best suited for

For babies between 5.5-30 pounds.


  • You can use batteries or plug it in
  • JPMA certified
  • Can last up to 4 hours on batteries
  • Has six total speed settings
  • Lightweight and portable


  • Assembly instructions aren’t easily understandable
View on Amazon


Prepare yourself for some trial and error as you figure out which seat angles or motions your baby prefers. It may take a while to find a baby swings, but they’re certainly worth it. You get to spend the day with your baby while letting the swing function as your babysitter. You no longer need to worry when your baby starts to fuss.

The best part is that the different motions, sounds, and toys give your child entertainment options to suit their moods. Lightweight battery-powered options even make it possible for you to use the swing outside.

Which one will you get?

Last update on 2024-05-27 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *