Evenflo vs Graco – Which Car Seat Brand to Pick?

A car seat is undoubtedly one of the most important purchases you’ll ever make as a parent. At some point during your research you want to make the Evenflo vs Graco comparison. Why? Because they’re one of the most popular brands around.

I’ll be comparing these two seat brands to see which one is the better option. We’ll look at their features, pros and cons, benefits they offer.

My Top Picks

How to Choose the Best Car Seat

In the battle of Evenflo vs Graco picking the right car seat for your needs can be challenging. This is especially true if you, like me, are a first-time father who has no clue where to start his search. Thankfully, I’ve picked up a few tips along the way which I’m sharing with you now.

Here’s what to keep in mind when searching for the best car seat.

Things to Look for in a Car Seat

A car seat needs to tick all kinds of boxes to serve your little one well.

Firstly, determine how much you’re willing to spend and take into account all of the necessary safety features such a seat should possess.

Secondly, consider the amount of time your child will be spending in the seat. You want your child to be as comfortable as possible so pay careful attention to the materials used in the seat’s construction.

Thirdly, think about your child’s current growth rate – is he or she a slow grower and will you get the most out of a single-stage car seat? Or is your child achieving their growth spurts like nobody’s business, and needs a convertible car seat?

What are the Benefits of Car Seats?

No responsible father should dream of going without a car seat. Even if it’s just for a quick trip to the convenience store. Car seats reduce the risk of injury or worse by a staggering 70%. In addition to its life-saving properties car seats are also beneficial because they provide your child with a safe space to sit or sleep while traveling. Finally, there is a range of car seats available that come in all sorts of shapes, sizes and colors.

Brand Matters

The brand behind the car seat is of the utmost importance. Always opt for a well-known brand, such as Graco or Evenflo, to ensure you are getting a product of the highest quality that meets the necessary safety standards. Both of these brands have earned their impressive reputations. Evenflo has been around since 1920 while Graco entered the market in 1942 – so it’s safe to say these guys know a thing or two about manufacturing car seats.

Appreciated Extras

Now that you know the basics it’s time to explore the extras. These features aren’t technically essential but will make your life a whole lot easier. Keep your eyes peeled for car seats that have easy installation processes, those that have thoughtful features like built-in cupholders and brands that offer a range of color options to pick from.

Graco Extend2Fit Convertible Car Seat

Graco Extend2Fit 2-in-1 Car Seat, Kenzie

The first Graco product on my list is the most popular: the Extend2Fit Convertible Car Seat. I compared this in another post before: Graco Extend2Fit vs 4Ever vs Slimfit.

This convertible car seat grows with your child from infant to toddler. It features extensive safety features while still providing high levels of comfort.

Its maximum weight capacity means it will be able to keep up with your child’s inevitable growth spurts. The seat features dual cup holders and is available in a variety of colors.

Who This Product is Ideal for

This car seat is ideal for rear-facing infants and for front-facing toddlers. It’s a great option for parents who don’t want to buy two separate car seats.

Why You Should Consider It

This car seat features a great deal of adjustability such as 10 headrest positions to choose from and a 6-position recline option. It also has an adjustable 5″ legroom extension panel. It’s easy to install, use, clean and maintain.

Product Specifications

  • Dimensions: 19.2 x 25.2 x 22.1 inches
  • Weight: 24.14lbs
  • Materials: Metal, plastic and machine-washable fabric
  • Capacity: infants from 4lb to 50lb and toddlers from 22lb to 65lb
  • Color: Black with white, pink, gray or orange, gray with blue or a trio of grays


  • Easy installation
  • Adjustable
  • Multiple color options
  • Accommodates a growing child


  • No carrying handle
  • Takes a couple of minutes to strap the child in
View on Amazon

Graco Slim Fit 3 in 1 Convertable Car Seat

Graco SlimFit 3 in 1 Car Seat -Slim & Comfy Design Saves Space in Your Back Seat, Darcie, One Size

Another Graco product that is worth mentioning is the Slim Fit 3 in 1 Convertable Car Seat. As the name suggests, this car seat boasts a slim design that is perfect for space-strapped vehicles. This versatile car seat will stick with you through all stages of your kid’s life: infant, toddler and child.

It has rotating cup holders, an integrated storage compartment and an instant latch system. It’s available in two stylish grayscale color options which the fashion-conscious father will appreciate.

Who This Product is Ideal for

This product is ideal for infants, toddlers and children. How’s that for an all rounder?

Why You Should Consider It

It has a 4-position recline feature, a 5-point harness system and has passed rigorous crash tests. Spill concerns will become a thing of the past as the seat is completely washable.

Product Specifications

  • Dimensions: 26.81″ x 19.88″ x 22.36″
  • Weight: 19.69lbs
  • Materials: Steel, polyester and machine-washable fabric
  • Weight Capacity: Infants from 5lbs to 40lbs, toddlers from 22lbs to 65lbs and children from 30lbs to 100lbs
  • Color options: Dark gray or light gray


  • Adjustable
  • Innovative design
  • Focuses on comfort
  • Accommodates a growing child


  • Latch is tough to tighten
  • Safety sticker retains heat
View on Amazon

Graco Affix Highback Booster Seat with Latch System

The last Graco product I’ll be discussing is the Affix Highback Booster Seat with Latch System. This product features a one-hand front latch system which is ideal for multitasking parents and their independent offspring alike.

Integrated cup holders and hideaway storage compartments make this a great option for big kids who are always on the go. It’s available in a striking red color.

Who This Product is Ideal for

This product is designed with children in mind and can comfortably seat kids who weigh up to 100lbs.

Why You Should Consider It

This car seat is fully adjustable and is easy enough to operate that your child can buckle up by themself. It also features energy-absorbing foam for enhanced impact resistance as well as temperature control.

Product Specifications

  • Dimensions: 15.5″ x 16.5″ x 26.75″
  • Weight: 9.8lbs
  • Materials: Metal, plastic and machine-washable fabric
  • Weight Capacity: 40lbs to 100lbs
  • Color options: Red


  • Easy to use
  • Lightweight
  • Adjustable
  • Converts to a backless booster


  • Headrest doesn’t lock well
  • Difficult to install
View on Amazon

Evenflo Tribute LX Converter Car Seat

Evenflo Tribute LX 2-in-1 Lightweight Convertible Car Seat, Travel Friendly (Saturn Gray)

Now it’s on to Evenflo. I’ll be introducing you to their most popular car seat: the Tribute LX Converter Car Seat. This fashionable car seat will securely hold your child from infant through to toddler.

A detachable side-strap cup holder is included in its design and the materials used in its construction are soft & supple. It’s available in an abundance of color options that will please you and stimulate your child.

Who This Product is Ideal for

This product is designed with infants and small toddlers in mind & every element of its design speaks to this fact.

Why You Should Consider It

If you want a car seat that looks good, this is your best option. It has four shoulder strap positions and an easy-to-operate harness system & buckle release system.

Product Specifications

  • Dimensions: 18.5″ x 22″ x 25.5″
  • Weight: 9.29lbs
  • Materials: Metal, plastic and polyester
  • Weight Capacity: Infants from 5lbs to 40lbs and toddlers from 22lbs to 40lbs
  • Color options: Black with gray, red, light blue, bright blue, pale pink, hot pink or pink floral


  • Inexpensive
  • Lightweight
  • Variety of color options


  • Cushioning is thin
  • Fabric is cumbersome to clean
  • Difficult to install
View on Amazon


When is the right time to buy a car seat?

You should have your car seat prepped and ready to go before your baby is even born. Thereafter you need to purchase a car seat that caters to your growing child.

What are the stages of car seats?

There are four stages of car seats. Rear-facing for infants, front-facing for children aged three to five, booster seats for children five years up to as old as 12 and the regular back seat of your car thereafter.

How can I tell if my child is seated properly?

First, check that the harness is tight enough – it should have no slack. Second, make sure that said harness and all straps are properly positioned as per your user manual. Third, ensure that your child is seated properly and that their head is properly supported & they are securely strapped in.


When we pit Evenflo vs Graco against one another, it’s clear that one brand emerges victorious. That brand would be Graco. Not only does Graco offer more products but their product quality simply trumps Evenflo’s. Sure, their products may be more expensive but when it comes to your child’s safety – no price is too high.

Another interesting comparison is between Evenflo vs Chicco brands in terms of the travel systems they offer or comparing ISOFIX to LATCH.

Last update on 2024-05-12 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *