Singer vs Janome Review

Many sewing enthusiasts know that sewing is a hobby that takes a lot of patience. It can take a while to learn how to sew something right, and many times it is often through trial and error. That’s why you should have a good quality machine. Singer vs Janome comparison naturally comes to mind when you are looking for a quality sewing machine. However, most people tend to stick to the machine they started with, often missing out on new products on the market that offer a lot more. In this review I will look at the pros, cons, similarities, and product information of these two brands. Don’t (necessarily) get stuck with your first machine you bought years ago.

Main Sewing Machine Quality Factors – Similarities and Differences

Price

Sewing machines from different brands all have various prices that are influenced by the brand, model type, and features included. Some of the more well-known brands tend to be pricey, however, you are sure you’re getting what you paid for. If, on the other hand, the machine you get is too cheap, you have to be very careful and think about it before you purchase it. Other factors can also affect the price, such as whether the machine is new or used. You always want value for your money, and from the list of my top picks, the Singer 4423 is the cheapest followed by the 4432. The Janome HD1000 comes next with the priciest on the list being the HD3000.

Stitch Options

Machines can have a varying number of stitch options such as a straight stitch, zig zag stitch for raw edges, straight stretch stitch for secure stitches, and so on. Singer has models with built-in stitches ranging from as low as 6 to 600, while Janome models range up to 510. The 4432 model has 32 built-in stitches while the 4423 has 23. The HD1000 has 14, while the HD3000 has 18.

Weight and Size of the Machine

A machine’s weight will matter if you have to move it often or store it away when not in use. Stand-alone and portable machines all have different weights, so before you select one, try lifting it up. For online purchases, ensure that you check the weight listed before buying. If you plan to use the machine in a stationary place, then getting a heavier machine can mean better quality as it is made of metal rather than a lot of plastic. Singer 4423 is the lightest weighing 14.6 lbs, followed by the 4432 at 15 pounds. The Janome models are the heaviest with the HD1000 weighing 16.8 pounds, and the HD3000 is 18.7 lbs.

Service and Warranty

When dealing with machines, you never know when something will go wrong. For this reason, always find out the warranty’s length and what is covered. Also, inquire if you can get your machine serviced locally, or you will have to mail it to them. Although both brands are known to provide high-quality products, they offer a 25-year warranty, which might give you confidence that the machines are made to last long.

Which one to choose: Singer vs Janome

While looking for a sewing machine, you are bound to come across these two brands. They both offer machines for beginners and advanced users while also having a good reputation.

If you are in search of an affordably priced sewing machine, then the Singer 4423 might be your best bet. If you’re more interested in a heavy-duty one, then the Janome HD3000 or the Singer models will do. For a machine with more stitch options, then the Singer 4432 may be an excellent choice.

All these models have a warranty of 25 years. No matter what sewing needs you to have, these four models should fit the bill.

Why choose singer sewing machines

It is among the biggest brands and has a good reputation. The company making Singer brand sewing machines also makes other brands so they understand what users want. Their entry-level models are very beginner-friendly, and anyone can use them. The more advanced models offer more features. However, some people think that the quality of new singer machines is lower than the original vintage ones making them hesitant to use them. This is however debatable as Singer have maintained their high-quality standard to date.

Why choose Janome sewing machines

Janome sewing machines are known to be of high quality, and they have an excellent reputation. Their machines are well-priced, meaning that you can get a quality machine that is within your budget. The machines are durable, especially for non-computerized ones, since they have fewer electrical parts. Even though they are priced per value, they are still more expensive than similar Singer models.

My Top Picks

Lightest option – Janome HD3000

The HD3000 is a heavy-duty mechanical sewing machine ideal for stitching heavy fabrics. Its powerful motor and features make it suitable for both advanced users and beginners. It produces consistent results despite not having many of the features found in other computerized sewing machines.

Product Information

  • Weight: 18.7 pounds
  • Dimensions: 16 x 11.3 x 7.2 inches
  • Warranty: 25 years
  • Speed: 860 stitches per minute
  • Color: large variety
  • Type: Mechanical

Who it’s suitable for

The Janome HD3000 is suitable for beginners and advanced users.

Pros

  • Easy to use
  • Sturdy and stable
  • It can stitch multilayer fabrics well
  • Has a strong motor with a stitch speed of 860 stitches per minute.
  • Quiet and runs smoothly
  • Excellent stitch quality
  • Multiple features
  • Portable can fit in small spaces
  • Relatively affordable when compared to other machines in its class

Cons

  • Thread cutters are not well placed, thus wasting a lot of thread
  • Cannot handle extra thick fabric as the needle may get stuck
  • Can be quite loud when sewing lighter fabrics

 

Lightest option – Janome HD1000

The Janome HD 1000 model is the best of both worlds because it is an industrial-grade machine that is easy to use. It is fast, versatile, and tough enough to handle most fabrics. It’s beginner-friendly because of its easy to use nature and its easy setup. Even for a beginner, the instruction book is easy to read and understand so you don’t get lost along the way.

Product Information

  • Weight: 16.8 pounds
  • Dimensions: 15.6 x 6.3 x 12.4 inches
  • Warranty: 25 years-limited
  • Speed: 840 stitches per minute
  • Type: Mechanical

Who it’s suitable for

The Janome HD1000 is also suitable for beginners and advanced users.

Pros

  • Easy to use
  • Heavy-duty design
  • Lightweight because it is made from durable aluminum
  • Beginner-friendly
  • Has an extra high presser foot
  • An automatic threader

Cons

  • Even though it is tough, it cannot stitch canvas, reptile skin, plastic, twill, and rubber
  • Clutch slips sometimes
  • Custom bobby pins also jam sometimes

 

Most versatile – Singer 4432

The 4432 model offers the most stitch options of the models in this list. It is a heavy-duty machine that has high switching speeds that let you produce quality work faster. For a more in-depth review of the machine, read my previous post – Singer 4432 vs 4423 Comparison.

Product Information

  • Weight: 15 pounds
  • Dimensions: 15.6 x 12 x 6.2 inches
  • Warranty: 90 days, 2 years and 25 years-limited
  • Speed: 1,100 stitches per minute
  • Type: Mechanical

Who it’s suitable for

The Singer 4432 is easy to use and thus suitable for beginners and experienced sewers.

Pros

  • Has reverse stitching to help you sew in reverse and reinforce your stitches.
  • Simple stitch selections allows you to change between stitches easily
  • Three-needle positions give you more control as you work
  • Customizable stitch length and width.
  • Can sew heavy fabrics.
  • Has twin needle capabilities
  • Has a seven-segment feed system, and the drop feed function can also be quite useful when quilting or sewing buttons.

Cons

  • LED lighting is poor.
  • Its dull color is considered a disadvantage

Singer 4432 vs 4423 Comparison

 

Most affordable – Singer 4423

The Singer 4423 is an all-rounded machine. It is dependable, affordable, and has various features and add-ons that can help you handle any sewing project you might have.

Product Information

  • Weight: 14.6 pounds
  • Dimensions: 15.6 x 12 x 6 inches
  • Warranty: 90 days, 2 years and 25 years-limited
  • Speed: 1,100 stitches per minute
  • Type: Mechanical

Who it’s suitable for

The Singer 4423 is also suitable for beginners and advanced users.

Pros

  • Easy to use
  • Great for beginners and advanced users
  • Great value for money
  • It has a limited 90-day warranty for adjustments, replacing bulbs, belts, and other attachments. A limited 2-year warranty for the electronic parts such as the motor and a limited 25-year warranty for the sewing machine head
  • The heavy-duty frame gives it stability and durability
  • An automatic needle threader
  • Loads of accessories

Cons

  • Can get quite loud while stitching
  • 23 built-in stitching options are still limited

Conclusion

We all have different sewing needs and preferences. Even with a tutorial or instructions, sometimes stitching your own clothes can be hard enough, but with the right machine, you can make the process a lot easier and faster. Your needs will greatly influence the machine you purchase, but with the help you got from this review, you might be in a better position to choose between Singer and Janome machine

Last update on 2020-12-02 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on pinterest
Share on email
Share on print

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *