Pampers Baby Dry vs Overnight – Let’s Get Unconfused!

pampers diaper

Pampers is one of the more popular diaper brands favored by new and experienced parents alike. One of the reasons this brand is so well-loved is that there are a number of different options to choose from. Two of the more common favorites you might want to compare are Pampers Baby Dry vs Overnight. What’s the difference between these two?

The difference between Baby Dry and Overnight is that Baby Dry has a more absorbent top layer constructed from polyester and polypropylene. Overnight has an ultra-soft top layer made of polypropylene, polyester and polyethylene. The addition of polyethylene makes the Overnight much softer. 

Pampers Baby Dry vs Swaddlers Overnight – Differences and Similarities

A number of standard features are found on all the Pampers options. The 12-hour protection feature was a firm favorite with the original Pampers Active Baby. Although that option is now discontinued, the 12-hour protection has been added to the Baby Dry. 

Pampers Swaddlers Overnights Diapers - Size 3, 66 Count, Disposable Baby Diapers, Night Time Skin Protection

There are also a few features that differentiate the Pampers Swaddlers Overnights and the Pampers Baby Dry. It’s important to know which option will suit your baby’s needs better. 

Pampers Baby-Dry Disposable Diapers Size 3, 204 Count, ECONOMY PACK PLUS (Packaging May Vary)


Since both of these options are from Pampers, they both sport the famous Pampers absorbent core. In addition, Baby Dry features five absorbent layers with a trio of air channels. These layers hold more urine and keep the baby drier than a Swaddlers. It’s estimated that the Baby Dry holds between 20% – 25% more liquid.

Wetness Indicator

The wetness indicator on both Baby Dry and Swaddlers is exactly the same until size four. At size four, Baby Dry doesn’t have any wetness indicators as it becomes quite obvious when the diaper’s full. 

Pampers Swaddlers continue to feature the wetness indicator in the form of a strip.


Both Baby Dry and Swaddlers feature soft, stretchy sides that offer a custom fit. A huge plus with both these options is that they provide movement similar to underwear. This means they move as your baby moves and have strong tabs to keep them in place to prevent sliding down or leakage when babies become more active and start crawling around. 

Swaddlers’ newborn sizes feature an umbilical cord notch. Baby Dry doesn’t have this feature. 


Swaddlers are designed to be soft and stretchy while the Baby Dry is both stretchy and breathable. Baby Dry is more breathable, which goes a long way to keep moisture from your baby’s skin. 

Changing Frequency

Baby Dry is primarily designed to keep babies dry overnight. Not having to wake the baby for every change will ensure they sleep through the night. While Swaddlers are great for sensitive skin, they will need to be changed before the 12-hour mark. 

Here’s a clip showing you how Swaddlers works for babies with sensitive skin! 

Other Alternatives to Pampers Baby Dry

There could be a number of reasons why you’d prefer an alternative to Baby Dry. If that’s the case, it helps to know how other options compare. Let’s look at a few! 

Pampers Baby Dry vs Huggies OverNites Diapers

Huggies Overnites Diapers are one of the more popular alternatives to all of the Pampers options. Like Pampers Baby Dry, Huggies claims to keep your baby dry for at least 12 hours. Let’s see how Huggies OverNites compares with the Baby Dry.

Huggies Overnites Nighttime Diapers, Size 3, 80 Ct


Huggies OverNites can absorb a considerable amount of liquid without leaking. This is due to the Huggies Leak Lock design that works by keeping the wetness away from your baby. This means there’s a very low risk of diaper rash


Huggies options feature a SnugFit waistband that allows the diapers to fit snugly and securely. Unlike some other generic options, the tabs on the OverNites are firm and keep the diaper firmly in place. 


Huggies and Pampers run in the same price range and feature similar features. So, if you’re looking for an alternative purely based on price, Huggies won’t be the option to consider. However, Huggies is the alternative most like Pampers Baby Dry.

Pampers Baby Dry Vs Target Up & Up Overnight

If you’re looking for a budget-friendly option similar to Baby Dry, then the Target Up & Up Overnight is worth considering. 


Parents seem to agree that this option doesn’t provide as much absorption as the Baby Dry. So, if you’re going to choose this option, it might not be a good idea to leave one diaper on for the full 12 hours as you would with the Baby Dry option. 


Target’s Up & Up seems to fit comfortably enough and is also soft enough to not irritate sensitive skin. Tabs are durable and do well to keep the diaper in place.


The Target brand’s diapers are convenient and inexpensive. A point worth noting is that if the diaper isn’t as absorbent, then you might end up doing more diaper changes than expected. You’ll then be buying a considerable amount more, which won’t really show you savings. This is especially the case with babies older than 4 months who eat and drink more. 

Pampers Baby Dry Vs Honest Overnights

Another favorite alternative to Baby Dry is the Honest Overnight Sleepy Sheep Diaper.

The Honest Company Clean Conscious Overnight Diapers | Plant-Based, Sustainable | Sleepy Sheep | Club Box, Size 6 (35+ lbs), 42 Count


Many parents agree about the super absorbency of the Honest brand, and three doesn’t seem to be a problem with keeping babies dry for the advertised 12 hours. This is as a result of the Night Absorb Core that’s made up of ultra-absorbent material.


Honest diapers feature soft, stretchy side panels with comfortable elastic waistbands. Sure-fit leg cuffs diaper blow-outs stay inside the diaper. Fastening tabs are strong and keep the diaper in place no matter how active the baby is!


As far as price goes, this alternative is considerably cheaper than Baby Dry. This makes it an ideal alternative to give you features similar to the Baby Dry at a more budget-friendly price!


When it comes to Pampers Baby Dry vs Overnight, one option isn’t necessarily better than the other. The Pampers Swaddlers Overnight is ideal for preemies, newborns, and little ones up to the age of four months. The nifty wetness indicator, umbilical cord notch, and ultra-soft liner make it the best option for new, sensitive skin. 

While you can continue using the popular Swaddlers, some parents opt for changing to Baby Dry after the fourth month. This is mostly because of the stronger tabs and the dry feature which is suited to bigger babies who’re eating and drinking more. If you’d like some more information on the top diaper brands, consider reading Pampers versus Huggies. Considering Pampers Swaddlers or Pampers Cruisers will also provide you with other options to consider!

Last update on 2024-06-17 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *